• Home
  • About Us
  • Courses
    • Mains
    • Prelims
  • Current affairs
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Forum
  • Shop
      • Cart

        0
    Have any question?
    (+91) 733 083 3391
    info@iasbee.com
    RegisterLogin
    IAS BEEIAS BEE
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Courses
      • Mains
      • Prelims
    • Current affairs
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Forum
    • Shop
        • Cart

          0

      CURRENT AFFAIRS

      • Home
      • Blog
      • CURRENT AFFAIRS
      • RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (13th November 2019)

      RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (13th November 2019)

      • Posted by BEE
      • Categories CURRENT AFFAIRS, Mains Capsule
      • Date November 14, 2019

      13th NOVEMBER, 2019

      RAJYA SABHA TELEVISION

       

      THE BIG PICTURE: CJI COMES UNDER RTI ACT

      The Chief Justice of India is a public authority and his office comes under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the Supreme Court ruled today in a landmark judgment, emphasizing that “in a constitutional democracy, judges can’t be above the law”. 

      Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi and three future Chief Justices were part of the constitution bench that agreed that transparency and accountability go hand-in-hand. The judges reaffirmed a 2010 Delhi High Court judgment and dismissed appeals by the Secretary General and Central Public Information Officer of the Supreme Court.

      The decision of the bench was penned by a 3:2 majority as Justice Ramana and Justice Chandrachud has given separate judgment.

      Background of the case

      • In 2007, RTI activist Subhash Chandra Aggarwal filed an RTI and asked for details of the assets of the judges. When his application was rejected, the matter reached the Central Information Commissioner (CIC) and CIC asked for information.
      • After that, the matter was challenged in Delhi High court. The High court said that the office of CJI comes under RTI but it was again challenged in Supreme Court. A hearing was held in the Supreme Court in April 2019 and the court had reserved the verdict.

      Delhi High Court’s Judgment in 2010

      • The Delhi High Court had said in a judgment on 10 January 2010 that the office of the Chief Justice comes under the purview of the RTI Act.  The Delhi High court said that judicial independence is not the privilege of the judge, but a responsibility on him. The High Court rejected the appeal of the apex court that judicial independence would be ‘obstructed’ by bringing the CJI office under the purview of RTI.
      • The High Court rejected the plea of the apex court that judicial independence would be ‘obstructed’ by bringing the CJI office under the purview of RTI. The General Secretary of the Supreme Court filed a petition against the decision and now SC has announced its verdict.
      • Attorney General (AG) KK Venugopal, representing the Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the Supreme Court, had said that sharing of information related to the collegium under the CJI’s office would embarrass the judges and the government and destroy judicial freedom.

       

      The verdict

      • The Right to Information and Right to Privacy are two sides of the same coin. None can take precedence over the other,” the court said in a judgment that said the Chief Justice’s office comes under the transparency law.
      • Bringing the office of the highest officials of the Apex Court under RTI will make the judiciary more accountable and it will increase the credibility of the judiciary in the eye of the public.
      • Justice Chandrachud said the judiciary cannot function in total insulation as judges enjoy a constitutional post and discharge a public duty. 
      • Justice Ramana said there should be balancing formula for the Right to Privacy and the Right to transparency, and the independence of the judiciary should be protected from any breach.

       Which body comes under it?

      Within the meaning of section 2 (H) of the RTI

      • Act only to the public authority
      • Any authority established by or under the constitution becomes public authority
      • Any authority by a law enacted by a parliament, state assembly, government order, notification etc
      • Any authority which is substantially funded by the government directly or indirectly

      Why the judiciary was reluctant to come under ambit of RTI?

      • After the Delhi high court verdict, many judges of many high courts declared their assets as sought under RTI act, this put the extra pressure on the chief justice of India to bring its office under the ambit of RTI.
      • But in ADR case, the SC had ruled about the elected representatives, that it was incumbent upon them to declare their assets, liabilities, educational qualifications and criminal antecedents if any.
      • The judiciary has always used the shield of independence of the judiciary to bypass any reform to judiciary. Subsequently the Supreme Court has declared National judicial appointment commission (NJAC) unconstitutional.

      The way forward 

      • The Supreme Court has issued the doctrine of proportionality vis-à-vis right to privacy on the independence of the judiciary. Judicial independency and accountability go hand in hand.
      • The “doctrine of proportionality” if it would have been applied to other wings of government would have ended up with judiciary rejecting it saying that we cannot read into the statutory provisions of certain doctrines merely because it suits the convenience of the person in question 
      • This judgment spells out the need to reconcile the judiciary under article 124 with the obligations of the judiciary to be a transparent institution under the RTI act.

       

      • Share:
      author avatar
      BEE

      Previous post

      April Monthly Current Affairs Quiz 2019
      November 14, 2019

      Next post

      November 14th Editorial
      November 14, 2019

      You may also like

      RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (26th November 2019)
      28 November, 2019

      26th NOVEMBERM, 2019 RAJYA SABHA TELEVISION   DESH-DESHANTAR: SC/ST & Constitutional empowerment Introduction  On 26th November 2019, India is witnessing its 70th year of the Constitution day. The constitution makers has taken into the account of the under privileged section …

      RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (22nd November 2019)
      28 November, 2019

      22nd NOVEMBER, 2019 RAJYA SABHA TELEVISION   VISHESH: ROLE OF GOVERNOR Introduction  Every time there is a hung assembly, it’s the governor who uses his discretion that often favors the party or alliance at the Centre. Whether it is Maharashtra …

      November 27th Editorial
      27 November, 2019

      27th November 2019 TOPIC:  Issues relating to development and management of Social Sector/Services relating to Health, Education, human resources. (Paper II) Discuss how sanitation cannot be a separate ideal without reference to other forms of deprivation. Introduction India’s high-profile Swacch …

      Search

      iasbee-Logo

      Latest Posts

      RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (26th November 2019)
      28Nov2019
      RAJYA SABHA TV /ALL INDIA RADIO (22nd November 2019)
      28Nov2019
      November 27th Editorial
      27Nov2019
      November 26th Editorial
      27Nov2019
      November 25th Editorial
      27Nov2019

      Latest Courses

      INDIAN POLITY

      INDIAN POLITY

      Free
      ART&CULTURE

      ART&CULTURE

      ₹200.00 ₹99.00
      ART&CULTURE

      ART&CULTURE

      ₹69.00
      ECOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT

      ECOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT

      ₹200.00 ₹99.00
      HISTORY-ANCIENT INDIA

      HISTORY-ANCIENT INDIA

      ₹300.00 ₹99.00
      Indian Economy

      Indian Economy

      ₹299.00 ₹99.00
      iasbee
      (+91) 733 083 3391
      info@iasbee.com
      Facebook Twitter

      Privacy

      • Privacy policy
      • Terms of use
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Place Orders with IASBEE
      • Refund policy

      Links

      • Courses
      • Blog
      • FAQs

      Copyright ©2019 All rights reserved by IASBEE. Powered by Gridlogs.

      Login with your site account

      Lost your password?

      Not a member yet? Register now

      Register a new account

      Are you a member? Login now